- Age of Steam
- Die Macher [tied w/Age of Steam for 1st place, but I'm having major trouble uploading the picture... sigh]
- Funkenschlag [referring to the original German game, not Power Grid]
- A Game of Thrones
- Arkham Horror
- Civilization/Advanced Civilization
- Descent: Journeys in the Dark
- Empire Builder [representing all crayon rails games]
- History of the World
- Paths of Glory
- Roads & Boats
- Scepter of Zavandor, The
- War of the Ring
The Pickers indicated a slight preference for the newest version of History of the World and the American edition of crayon rails (Empire Builder). There was a dead heat between Civilization & Advanced Civilization, with one participant so turned off by Advanced Civ that he refused to vote for the combination.
There was also a lot of griping from the Pickers about how games made it onto the nominations list - "It NEVER takes us 3 hours to play [blank]." Remember, the nominations were compiled from lists of seven games chosen by the Pickers based on their personal experience with these games.
Labels: Subjective Yumminess